AI vs Readers

Top books: History

AI scores each book across five 10-point criteria. Readers vote on the same scale, so the algorithmic and reader rankings can sit side by side.

Genres

Rankings by category

AI

Top 100

AI-rated books: 64. Reader-ranked books: 0.

#3

Author: Jonathan Harris

Setting: Constantinople / Istanbul, Turkey

AI #3

Sweep8/10Adventure8/10Period detail8/10Hero in action8/10Epic finish8/10
#27

Author: Richard Snow

Setting: Disneyland, Anaheim, California

AI #27

Sweep8/10Adventure7/10Period detail8/10Hero in action8/10Epic finish7/10
#40

Author: Susan Orlean

Setting: Los Angeles Public Library, Los Angeles, California

AI #40

Sweep8/10Adventure7/10Period detail8/10Hero in action7/10Epic finish8/10
#48

Author: Truman Capote

Setting: Holcomb, Kansas

AI #48

Sweep7/10Adventure7/10Period detail8/10Hero in action7/10Epic finish8/10
#52

Author: Hélène Lee, Bill Howell

Setting: Pinnacle, Jamaica

AI #52

Sweep8/10Adventure7/10Period detail7/10Hero in action7/10Epic finish7/10
#60

Author: Erik Larson

Setting: London, England

AI #60

Sweep8/10Adventure7/10Period detail7/10Hero in action7/10Epic finish7/10
#62

Author: Kiyoshi Tanimoto

Setting: Hiroshima, Japan

AI #62

Sweep7/10Adventure7/10Period detail7/10Hero in action7/10Epic finish8/10
#64

Author: Elie Wiesel

Setting: Auschwitz-Birkenau, Oświęcim, Poland

AI #64

Sweep7/10Adventure7/10Period detail7/10Hero in action8/10Epic finish7/10

Criteria

History

Sweep

Scale of the story, journey, period, or conflict.

Adventure

Momentum and sense of movement.

Period detail

Credibility of era, places, and details.

Hero in action

Whether decisions and actions carry the story.

Epic finish

A close that feels worthy of a large story.